Casey's New Buffalo

Casey's New Buffalo Kitchen Daily Open @ Noon - 10pm! Bar Open til Midnight! Last call at 1:30 A.M. on Friday and Saturday!
(1055)

We are focused on bringing you the highest quality food, sourced locally whenever possible. Casey’s is reminiscent of a traditional Chicago-style grill, with its antique tin ceiling, historic Art Deco bar and hardwood floor, but includes some decorative influences from its lakeside location. There are plenty of TV's, so you won't miss the big game and we host live entertainment every weekend. When

the weather’s fine, eat and drink in Casey’s Back Yard, a delightful landscaped patio, featuring our outdoor Ice House bar (originally a building used to store ice cut from the lake in the winter). On weekends, our customers often tarry after dinner to enjoy live music with friends, old and new.

What an Exciting Weekend Ahead for Flag Day!Friday & Saturday Summer Vibes with Party Proz Entertainment Dj SUBOH and Gu...
06/11/2026

What an Exciting Weekend Ahead for Flag Day!

Friday & Saturday Summer Vibes with Party Proz Entertainment Dj SUBOH and Guests! Beats drop at 10pm!

Sunday Pride Drag Diva Review - Private Pride Event! Tickets Available!!! Followed by Michael & Amber Acoustic on the Patio!

Come on Down to Casey's New Buffalo!!!

Always a Vibe on Fridays and Saturdays with Party Proz Entertainment!!!
06/09/2026

Always a Vibe on Fridays and Saturdays with Party Proz Entertainment!!!

A little bit sweet, a little bit strong… just how we like our nights out 🍓🍸See you on the patio.
06/07/2026

A little bit sweet, a little bit strong… just how we like our nights out 🍓🍸
See you on the patio.

Guess who’s back this weekend?!?!Come by on Friday AND Saturday after 10 pm for drinks and dancing here at Casey’s!
06/04/2026

Guess who’s back this weekend?!?!

Come by on Friday AND Saturday after 10 pm for drinks and dancing here at Casey’s!

We ARE open today. The old girl is getting a much needed beauty treatment today, but you can come to our Barton Street p...
06/03/2026

We ARE open today. The old girl is getting a much needed beauty treatment today, but you can come to our Barton Street parking lot and enter the patio or duck in the front past the painters!
Sorry for the inconvenience.

Hey guys! Did you know that Casey’s Icehouse was originated in 1841?!?! Before it was ever turned into an outdoor bar it...
06/03/2026

Hey guys! Did you know that Casey’s Icehouse was originated in 1841?!?! Before it was ever turned into an outdoor bar it was originally a functional icehouse where workers stored massive blocks of ice harvested from the nearby Galien River during the winter, insulating them with sawdust so they could last through the summer months!

Now the icehouse gives you cold beers and yummy cocktails to sit around our “secret garden”.

So, if you ever wondered what our staff means when we say, “go check out the icehouse” we really mean the icehouse!

Casey’s has been a historical monument in New Buffalo! Come check out this massive piece of history only here at Casey’s.

Did you know Casey’s has an amazing back patio? We like to think of it as our “secret garden”.. if you know you know… an...
06/02/2026

Did you know Casey’s has an amazing back patio? We like to think of it as our “secret garden”.. if you know you know… and well…. NOW YOU KNOW.

Come by and have some yummy food like our chicken shawarma bowl (pictures for reference;), or an amazing cocktail like our ube coconut martini! We promise, you won’t be disappointed.

PS, we’re dog friendly!

Join Casey's New Buffalo for Pride Drag Diva Review June 14th! Fundraiser for OutCenter Southwest Michigan!! Tickets av...
05/29/2026

Join Casey's New Buffalo for Pride Drag Diva Review June 14th! Fundraiser for OutCenter Southwest Michigan!! Tickets available online! Patio will still be open for regular business! Grab your tickets at Casey's New Buffalo or Link is Found on our Event Page! Pride Drag Diva Review

DJ Double E and DJ Navic in the house tonight 9pm-1am!
05/25/2026

DJ Double E and DJ Navic in the house tonight 9pm-1am!

Join us for Mother’s Day! Live Music 1-4pm from Beth Newman Niemann!!!! Patio is OPEN!
05/10/2026

Join us for Mother’s Day! Live Music 1-4pm from Beth Newman Niemann!!!! Patio is OPEN!

Address

136 North Whittaker Street
New Buffalo, MI
49117

Opening Hours

Monday 12pm - 10pm
Tuesday 12pm - 10pm
Wednesday 12pm - 10pm
Thursday 12pm - 10pm
Friday 12pm - 10pm
Saturday 12pm - 10pm
Sunday 12pm - 10pm

Telephone

+12694696400

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Casey's New Buffalo posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Establishment

Send a message to Casey's New Buffalo:

Shortcuts

Share