Toasty's Tavern

Home
United States
Louisville, KY
Toasty's Tavern

A neighborhood watering hole located in the Shelby Park neighborhood of Louisville, Kentucky serving fine food and drinks. Open 5:00 p.m. to close daily.

Kitchen Hours
Mon - Thurs 11am - 10pm
Fri - Sat 11am - 11pm
Sun 11am - 9pm

09/15/2026

Toastys 6 Year Birthday Party!!

Celebrate Six Classy Years!

SIX YEARS OF INSTAGRAMMING (ALMOST)
EVERYONE’S FAVORITE BURGER IN TOWN!

Since 2020, a.k.a. these uncertain times, Toasty’s Tavern has been keeping Shelby Park classy with fine American comfort food, cold drinks, and of course, our World Famous Magic Dust® & Toasty’s Sauce® family of products.

Now we’re celebrating six big years with a big block party on our back parking lot with all our friends and neighbors. You’re invited! Come hungry, bring your friends and stay awhile. It’s all happening Sunday, October 11th from 2 to 8 p.m... and admission won’t cost you one thin dime!

Sunday October 11th • 2–8pm • Free!

FOOD & DRINK Specials • Competent DEEJAYS • COOL Vendors • Good VIBES

Toasty’s Tavern
1258 S. SHELBY STREET (at Camp)
In Beautiful Shelby Park!

DINE IN OR CARRY OUT • MAJOR CREDIT CARDS ACCEPTED
KIDS DO NOT EAT FREE • JAMES PRESTON APPROVED

Artwork 🎨 by Michael C Powell

Full list of vendors, activities and djs coming very very soon!

09/11/2026

A new dessert special has entered the villa 💅 Bourbon Buttermilk Pie with a Cinnamon Whip whip on top 😋
Available while supplies last as usual!

Some fun news coming early next week as well so keep your eyes peeled 👀

09/04/2026

Have you tried one of our more popular new summer menu items, the Zo Dog?? Named after a little fuzzy friend of Toasty who went by the name of Zoe. An all beef hot dog topped with chili lime mayo and pickled red onions, can be made vegan as well! The perfect little snack for these insanely hot days we've been having.

09/03/2026

Shirley Temple Upside Down Cake!
Brown sugar cake, vanilla, Ale-8, maraschino cherries, topped with a grenadine whipped cream!

Available while supplies last!!

09/01/2026

New Monthly Margarita Just Dropped !!
The Fig Margarita 🍹
Fig Syrup, Lime Juice and Triple Sec 😋
This is the perfect beverage to cool yourself w the insane temps this week, pairs perfectly with a side of fries and a couple of burgers!

08/21/2026

Things are getting a little bananas over at Toastys this weekend !
Bananas Foster Upside Down Cake 🎂
Brown sugar cake topped with caramelized bananas 🍌 😋

Come try a slice while supplies last!
Also, take a pic in our new cut out sign, make memories that will last a life time and tag us in those photos !

08/15/2026

Paw Paw Bundt Cake 🎂
Moist Vanilla Bundt Cake with Paw Paw Puree baked in with a Paw Paw Curd on top!!
The perfect dessert after a plate of fries and a smashburger, available while supplies last!

08/14/2026

Its hot as hell outside 😩
Heres a picture of a cheeseburger 🍔

08/07/2026

A New Photo Op Has Emerged!
Needing to preserve the memory of your favorite burger while capturing a silly moment w friends and family??
We've got ya covered!
Featured on the sign are Toastys himself, his good pal Melba, our little neighborhood kitty Mable and the loveable pooch Levi!
Please come take a pic and tag us in all the photos so I can justify the ridiculous amount of hours it took me to paint this thing.

08/05/2026

August Monthly Soup Special 🍲 😋

Chilled Corn Soup topped with basil oil. KY grown corn, corn stock, oat milk, onion, garlic, and black pepper...soooo good!
Come snag a bowl today and dip a few fries in there...for science.

Address

1258 S. Shelby
Louisville, KY
40204

Telephone

+15026147094

Website

http://www.toastystavern.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Toasty's Tavern posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Establishment

Send a message to Toasty's Tavern:

Want your establishment to be the top-listed Bar/pub in Louisville?