Toasty's Tavern

Home
United States
Louisville, KY
Toasty's Tavern

Call Directions Website Contact the establishment

A neighborhood watering hole located in the Shelby Park neighborhood of Louisville, Kentucky serving fine food and drinks. Open 5:00 p.m. to close daily.

Kitchen Hours
Mon - Thurs 11am - 10pm
Fri - Sat 11am - 11pm
Sun 11am - 9pm

10/31/2026

Spooky Season is the perfect time for some homemade Hot Apple C***r 🍎
Served N/A but tastes extra good if you add bourbon or rum 😜
Available while its available!

10/30/2026

Happy Halloween Weekend 🎃
We've got a killer burger special lined up for ya!
The Cowboy Burger!
Swiss, pickled jalapeños, crispy onions, and house BBQ sauce....yeeehaww !!
Open normal hours all weekend!
See ya soon!!

10/27/2026

Toastys Halloween Costume Contest!!

Win $100 Toastys Gift Card!

We thought it would be fun for folks to dress either as Toasty or Melba this Halloween 🎃
If you still need a costume and feel like dressing as either character send us a photo of you in costume. We'll pick the best Toasty and Melba costumes and award each person $100!!

Photos of Toasty and Melba are in the slide show for reference!

Good luck!!

10/26/2026

Huge thanks to everyone who came out yesterday to celebrate Toastys 6th Bday Party!! There are still a few limited edition stickers available, theyll be in the free sticker tray while supplies last!

10/23/2026

SIX YEARS OF TOASTY'S!!

Six years of burgers, beers, questionable decisions and Instagramming (almost) everyone's favorite burger in town. We're throwing ourselves a BIG OL' BIRTHDAY PARTY and you're invited!

We're taking over the back lot for an afternoon of food, drinks, dancing, weird stuff, wonderful people and a whole bunch of our favorite local vendors!

CHECK OUT THIS ABSOLUTELY STACKED VENDOR LINEUP:

🔮 Rays Aura Portraits
🪄 Uncle Red Magic
🎤 Karaoke with Katie
🍦 Rettas Scoops
🐅 Hey Tiger
🧵 Heart Thread Collective
🌿 Freaks of Nature
🪲 Beetles, Bones & Bouquets
🦋 Idlewild Butterfly Farm
🎨 B3yond Reality Creations

PLUS we've got: 🍔 Food & drink specials
🎶 Music from some Louisville's best DJs
Dancing, hanging out, and general birthday shenanigans 🤪

📅 SUNDAY, OCTOBER 25TH
⏰ 2–8 PM
📍 TOASTY'S TAVERN — 1258 S. Shelby St.
🎟️ FREE TO ATTEND!

Bring your friends, bring your neighbors, bring that person who's somehow never had a Toasty's burger.

SIX YEARS DOWN, A MILLION MORE BURGERS TO GO. 🍔💛

SEE YOU IN THE BACK LOT!

10/22/2026

Toastys Six Year Bday Party is this Sunday!!
Everyone who attends will receive a very limited free sticker for the party to add to your collection! 1 per guest!
The event starts at 2pm and goes til 8pm!
Djs, Magicians, Karaoke, Aure Portraits and so much more!!
Spread the word and we'll see ya there!

10/20/2026

We've got a tasty new cocktail on special this week!!
Apple Pie Old Fashioned!
Marker’s Mark, house made apple butter, black walnut bitters & vanilla liqueur ....damn!

Also just want to remind you that our SIX YEAR BIRTHDAY PARTY IS ON SUNDAY 🎂 🥳
Loads of cool vendors, rad djs, great drink specials, karaoke, magicians and much more!!
Tell all your friends and we'll see ya this week!

10/14/2026

Toasty's Smashburger with a Side of Fries 🍟

Smashed Patty, Griddled Onions, American Cheese, Pops Pickles and our signature Toasty's Sauce 😋

The perfect snack for lunch or dinner 🍽
Open Tues-Sunday 11am til close

📸: Odd Man Out

10/08/2026

🎉 TOASTYS 6 YEAR BIRTHDAY PARTY — NEW DATE!! 🎉

SAME PARTY! NEW DATE!

Due to some less-than-classy weather forecasted for this Sunday, we're moving our big birthday bash to SUNDAY, OCTOBER 25TH!

Celebrate Six Classy Years! (Just two weeks later than originally planned.)

SIX YEARS OF INSTAGRAMMING (ALMOST) EVERYONE'S FAVORITE BURGER IN TOWN!

Since 2020, a.k.a. these uncertain times, Toasty's Tavern has been keeping Shelby Park classy with fine American comfort food, cold drinks, and of course, our World Famous Magic Dust® & Toasty's Sauce® family of products.

Now we're celebrating six big years with a big block party on our back parking lot with all our friends and neighbors. You're invited! Come hungry, bring your friends and stay awhile. It's all happening Sunday, October 25th from 2 to 8 p.m. and admission won't cost you one thin dime!

We apologize for the delay, but apparently Mother Nature had other plans. We're giving her two weeks to get it together.

Sunday October 25th • 2–8pm • Free!

FOOD & DRINK Specials • Competent DEEJAYS • COOL Vendors • Good VIBES

Toasty's Tavern
1258 S. SHELBY STREET (at Camp)
In Beautiful Shelby Park!

DINE IN OR CARRY OUT • MAJOR CREDIT CARDS ACCEPTED

KIDS DO NOT EAT FREE • JAMES PRESTON APPROVED

PLEASE SPREAD THE WORD ABOUT THE NEW DATE! ❤️🍔

10/01/2026

Its the first of the month and that means its time for our monthly margarita special 😋
The Pumpkin Pie Margarita 🍹
Pumpkin pie puree, pumpkin liqueur, blanco tequila and lime juice.....just in time for spooky season!

Also, please refer to slide #4 and let us know how you rank these piles of candy in the comments below.....for science 🤓

Address

1258 S. Shelby
Louisville, KY
40204

Telephone

+15026147094

Website

http://www.toastystavern.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Toasty's Tavern posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.