The Old Fashioned Supper Club

09/12/2026

🚨 PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT:

If you've been hearing people whispering about our Cowboy Butter Prime Rib... it's not a tall tale, it's the real deal 🤠🥩

At this point, it's developing a fan club.
We've watched grown adults close their eyes after the first bite. We've seen people "accidentally" steal a taste off someone else's plate. We can't confirm anyone has licked the buttery drippings off the plate....but we also can't deny it.

🔥 Here's the (great) problem: We've been SELLING OUT! SO, if your plan was to roll in at 8:00P and "see what's left"... your future self is going to be eating a salad and questioning your life choices.

🍻 Happy Hour starts at 4P - shoot the breeze, enjoy the company & have a delicious meal.

📍 The Old Fashioned Supper Club
📍 Newburg, WI
📞 Call now to reserve your time: 262-685-0012

Come hungry. Bring friends. Order the Prime. Thank us later.

09/11/2026

🎣 FRI-YAY FISH FRY 🎣

Join us for a Wisconsin tradition done right—with something for everyone! Not in the mood for fish? We got you covered!

🌟 Choose from Cod, Lake Perch or Jumbo Shrimp:
🧨 Crispy Fried (Gluten-Free)
🧈 Butter-Poached
🌶️ Blackened

Friday Menu Includes:
🥩 Hand-cut ribeyes, tenderloin filets & NY Strip steaks
🍝 Fresh pasta dishes
🥗 Crisp salads

🥣 Enjoy our scratch-made soup, sip on one of our handcrafted cocktails or mocktails, and save room for our freshly baked desserts 🍰

Whether you're craving a classic Friday Fish Fry or looking to try something new, we've got your table waiting!

📍 The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3497 E. Hwy 33, Newburg, WI 53060
📞 262-685-0012

Come hungry, bring your friends, and let us take care of dinner. We can't wait to serve you!

Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers TMJ4 News Wisconsin Supper Clubs FOX6 News Milwaukee Tour Ozaukee MKEeeeEats WISN 12 NEWS Only Wisconsin Things

09/11/2026

At The OFSC, we take great pride in serving our guests fresh, flavorful, scratch-made meals.

As a true, traditional supper club, we look forward to creating a memorable, immersive evening & we hope you enjoy every moment of your time with us!

09/05/2026

⭐Saturday Night is Made for Date Night⭐

Leave the cooking to us and treat your special someone to a relaxing evening at The Old Fashioned Supper Club.

Sink your knife into our legendary Prime Rib, savor a perfectly grilled, succulent steak, and enjoy handcrafted cocktails in a classic supper club atmosphere that Wisconsin is famous for.

Whether it's your first date, your hundredth date, or simply a night away from the kitchen, there's no better place to slow down, reconnect, and enjoy an exceptional meal together ❤

🥩 Cowboy Butter Prime Rib
🔥 Hand-Cut Steaks
🍝Fresh Pasta
🍸 Classic Cocktails
🎶 Great Company & Supper Club Charm

Doors open at 4 PM.

Make tonight a date night worth remembering at The Old Fashioned Supper Club in Newburg.

3498 E Hwy 33
Newburg, WI 53060
262-685-0012

Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers TMJ4 News Wisconsin Supper Clubs FOX6 News Milwaukee Tour Ozaukee Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Explore Wisconsin MKEeeeEats Wanderin Wisconsin WISN 12 NEWS Only Wisconsin Things

09/04/2026

Tonight’s Feature:
A Traditional Wisconsin Fish Fry! Join us this evening to enjoy a true classic, prepared your way and don't forget the handcrafted Old Fashioneds 🥃😀

🐟Select from Golden Fried, Poorman’s Lobster, Butter Poached, or Blackened features.

🍵Soup du Jour | Shrimp & Scallop Bisque

🍒Dessert | Cherry Cheesecake

The Old Fashioned Supper Club Tour Ozaukee Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers TMJ4 News Wisconsin Supper Clubs FOX6 News Milwaukee Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Explore Wisconsin MKEeeeEats Wanderin Wisconsin WISN 12 NEWS Only Wisconsin Things

09/03/2026

THURSDAY, THURSDAY, THURSDAY 📣
What's for dinner? No clue? Join us on this rainy evening for our Thursday night special:
💸Buy One Entree, Get $10 Off the Second!

Soup of the Day:
🥔 Loaded Baked Potato

Dessert of the Day:
🍫 Triple Chocolate Layer Cake

Travis will be serving up our Old Fashioned Happy Hour Specials from 4-5P, while Tabitha & Hunter are cooking your favorite meals until 9P.

We'll see ya soon 😁

The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3497 E Hwy 33
Newburg WI 53060
262-685-0012

Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers TMJ4 News Wisconsin Supper Clubs FOX6 News Milwaukee Tour Ozaukee Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Explore Wisconsin MKEeeeEats Wanderin Wisconsin WISN 12 NEWS

08/29/2026

🤠🔥 TONIGHT'S THE NIGHT! 🔥🤠

If you haven't had our Cowboy Butter & Bourbon-Infused Prime Rib - you are missing out! Slow-roasted to perfection and topped with our rich, flavorful cowboy butter & injected with a smoky bourbon, it's everything a Saturday night supper should be. 🥩🥃

Each Prime Rib meal includes:
🍢 Relish tray
🥗 Soup or salad
🥐 Warm rolls
🥔 Your choice of potato

Is it enough food for 3 people? Probably - but we want you to leave full & happy :)

📍 The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3497 E. Hwy 33
Newburg, WI 53060

📞 Reservations: 262-685-0012

Sneak peak: if you're into soup like we are, we have a surprise for you that will be announced next week 😉 stay tuned!

Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers TMJ4 News Wisconsin Supper Clubs Tour Ozaukee FOX6 News Milwaukee WISN 12 NEWS MKEeeeEats Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Explore Wisconsin

08/28/2026

🎣 FRI-YAY FISH FRY 🎣

Join us for a Friday night Wisconsin tradition —with something for everyone! Not in the mood for fish? We got you covered!

🌟 Choose from Cod, Lake Perch or Jumbo Shrimp:
🧨 Crispy Fried (Gluten-Free)
🧈 Butter-Poached
🌶️ Blackened

Friday Menu Includes:
🥩 Hand-cut ribeyes, tenderloin filets & NY Strip steaks
🍝 Fresh pasta dishes
🥗 Crisp salads

Sip on one of our handcrafted cocktails or mocktails, and save room for our freshly baked desserts 🍰 Our scratch-made soup for tonight is: Mediterranean Shrimp Orzo 🍵 Too warm for soup? We have Ice cream drinks 🍨

Whether you're craving a classic Friday Fish Fry or looking to try something new, we've got your table waiting!

📍 The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3497 E. Hwy 33, Newburg, WI 53060
📞 262-685-0012

Come hungry, bring your friends, and let us take care of dinner. We can't wait to serve you!

Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers TMJ4 News Wisconsin Supper Clubs FOX6 News Milwaukee Tour Ozaukee Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Explore Wisconsin Wanderin Wisconsin MKEeeeEats Only Wisconsin Things

08/22/2026

🥩 SATURDAY NIGHT STEAK SPECIAL! 🥩
Tonight at The Old Fashioned Supper Club, bring your favorite person and dig into our Steak for Two! ❤️

🥩 TWO NY STRIP STEAKS
🥔 Your choice of potato
🥦 Sautéed vegetable
💰 Just $55 for TWO!

And don’t forget… our incredible Cowboy Butter Prime Rib is also on the menu tonight! 🔥 While supplies last!

Come hungry, bring a friend, and make it a Saturday night to remember!

📍 The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E. Hwy 33, Newburg, WI 53060
📞 262-685-0012

Reservations recommended!
Dine in only :)

The Old Fashioned Supper Club Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers TMJ4 News Wisconsin Supper Clubs FOX6 News Milwaukee Tour Ozaukee Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Explore Wisconsin Wanderin Wisconsin MKEeeeEats The Wisconsin Explorer

08/20/2026

Join us for an Old Fashioned Happy Hour!
2 for 1 cocktails, beer, mocktails & more 🍻
🕓 Daily from 4-5PM
🍤 With purchase of an appetizer (dine in only)
🍹 Rail cocktails, martinis, tappers, canned and bottled beer

The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E Hwy 33
Newburg WI 53060
262-685-0012

Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers TMJ4 News Wisconsin Supper Clubs FOX6 News Milwaukee Tour Ozaukee Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Explore Wisconsin Wanderin Wisconsin MKEeeeEats

At The OFSC, we take great pride in serving our guests fresh, flavorful, scratch-made meals.

As a true, traditional supper club, we look forward to creating a memorable, immersive evening & we hope you enjoy every moment of your time with us!