What are the opening hours?

Thursday 4pm - 10pm Friday 4pm - 10pm Saturday 4pm - 10pm

https://www.facebook.com/488211457707248/

The Old Fashioned Supper Club

Home
United States
Newburg, WI
The Old Fashioned Supper Club

Call Directions

At The OFSC, we take great pride in serving our guests fresh, flavorful, scratch-made meals.

As a true, traditional supper club, we look forward to creating a memorable, immersive evening & we hope you enjoy every moment of your time with us!

10/31/2026

🔥🥩 SATURDAY NIGHT CALLS FOR COWBOY BUTTER PRIME RIB! 🥩🔥

If you've been craving something absolutely mouthwatering, we've got your dinner plans covered! 🤠

Tonight at The Old Fashioned Supper Club, we're serving up our incredible Cowboy Butter Prime Rib — slow-roasted to tender, juicy perfection and packed with flavor that'll have you thinking about your next bite before you've finished the first! 🤤

But that's not all! Our kitchen is firing on all cylinders with a FULL MENU featuring something for everyone!
🥩 Hand-cut steaks
🤠 Our signature Cowboy Butter Prime Rib
🍝 Fresh, delicious pasta
🍤 Seafood favorites
🥗 Crisp, fresh salads
🍽️ Classic supper club favorites and so much more!

Whether you're craving a perfectly cooked steak, indulging in prime rib, or looking for all your supper club favorites, we've got a seat waiting for you!

❤️ Come hungry. Leave happy. Make it a Saturday night worth savoring!

📍 The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E Hwy 33
West Bend, WI 53095
📞 262-685-0012

Tag your dinner date, gather your favorite people, and come see us tonight! 🍻🥩

The Old Fashioned Supper Club Wisconsin Supper Clubs Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers FOX6 News Milwaukee TMJ4 News Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Explore Wisconsin WISN 12 NEWS Milwaukee Brewers

10/30/2026

🐟🔥 FRIDAY FISH FRY IS CALLING… AND WE’RE READY FOR YOU! 🔥🐟

There’s no better way to kick off the weekend than a good old-fashioned Wisconsin Fish Fry! Come hungry and let us take care of dinner!

🍽️ FRIDAY NIGHT FEATURES:
🐟 Our Friday Fish Fry favorites
🥣 SEAFOOD CHOWDER – Today's soup of the day, and the perfect way to warm up!
🥩 Our full menu featuring incredible steaks, fresh pasta, crisp salads, and so much more!
🍎 ONE LAST BITE! 🍎
It's your LAST CHANCE this weekend to get your hands on our deeply loved CARAMEL APPLE CUSTARD CHEESECAKE! ❤️
That's right… this is its FINAL APPEARANCE of the season! If you've been waiting to try it (or come back for another slice), this is your weekend. Don't miss out!

Bring your family, grab your friends, and make Friday night delicious!

📍 The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E. Hwy 33
Newburg, WI 53060
📞 262-685-0012

GREAT FOOD. GOOD COMPANY. A LITTLE OLD-FASHIONED HOSPITALITY.

We’ll save you a 🐟The Old Fashioned Supper ClubeWisconsin Supper ClubsWisconsin Supper Club ChasersFOX6 News Milwaukee NTour OzaukeeMilwaukee Journal SentineluExplore WisconsinlMKEeeeEatssOnly Wisconsin ThingssWISN 12 NEWSMilwaukee BrewerswMilwaukee Brewers HighlightseBrew Crew Ball Brew Crew Ball

10/29/2026

⚾️🏆 THE BREWERS ARE WORLD SERIES CHAMPIONS… NOW LET’S CELEBRATE WISCONSIN STYLE! 🏆⚾️

🍖🔥 FALL-OFF-THE-BONE BABY BACK RIBS ARE CALLING YOUR NAME! 🔥🍖

Whether you’re still celebrating the Brew Crew’s INCREDIBLE World Series victory or just looking for a reason to get out and enjoy a delicious meal, we’ve got you covered! 💙💛

Our tender, slow-roasted baby back ribs are packed with mouthwatering flavor and so tender they practically fall right off the bone! 🤤 Slather on that BBQ goodness, grab your favorite drink, and let us handle dinner tonight!

⚾️ WORLD SERIES CHAMPS & RIBS ON THE TABLE? THAT’S A WIN-WIN! 🍻

Bring your family, round up your friends, and come hungry! We can’t wait to serve you at The Old Fashioned Supper Club! ❤️

📍 The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E Hwy 33, Newburg, WI 53060

📞 Call us at 262-685-0012

🔥 Great food. Good drinks. Wisconsin pride. What more could you ask for?!

👇 WHO’S READY FOR SOME RIBS?! Tag your crew and make dinner plans with us! 🍖⚾️💙💛

Brew Crew Ball The Old Fashioned Supper Club Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers TMJ4 News Wisconsin Supper Clubs FOX6 News Milwaukee Milwaukee Journal Sentinel MKEeeeEats Only Wisconsin Things WISN 12 NEWS

10/23/2026

⚾️🍺 SATURDAY NIGHT AT THE OLD FASHIONED SUPPER CLUB! 🧀🥩

We’re bringing the heat this Saturday with our INCREDIBLE Cowboy Butter Prime Rib and a little nod to our beloved BREWERS! 💙💛⚾️

Okay, so it’s not a brat… but trust us, this one deserves a spot in the starting lineup! 😍🔥

🥖 WE'RE SERVING UP OUR PRIME RIB DIP SANDWICH — JUST $18!
🤤 Tender, mouthwatering prime rib piled high on a fluffy hoagie bun
🧅 Loaded with grilled onions and mushrooms
🧀 Topped with melted provolone cheese
🥣 Served with savory au jus for dipping
🍟 Comes with a side of golden, crispy French fries!

Now THAT'S a sandwich worth cheering for! 🙌⚾️

And if you're craving something a little more classic, don't miss our famous Cowboy Butter Prime Rib — rich, savory, buttery goodness that makes Saturday night extra special! 🥩🔥

🍻 Grab your friends, wear your Brewers blue and gold, and join us for great food, cold drinks, and a whole lot of Wisconsin flavor!

📍 The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E. Hwy 33, West Bend, WI 53095
📞 262-685-0012

❤️ Come hungry. Leave happy. Old Fashioned Supper Club FWisconsin Supper Club ChasersTMJ4 NewslMilwaukee BrewerseMilwaukee Brewers HighlightseFOX6 News MilwaukeeTour OzaukeeiMilwaukee Journal SentineluWisconsin Supper ClubsiOnly Wisconsin Things OWISN 12 NEWS Things WISN 12 NEWS

10/23/2026

🐟 FRIDAY NIGHT FISH FRY AT THE OLD FASHIONED SUPPER CLUB! 🐟
🍻 TGIF! There’s no better way to kick off the weekend than with a delicious Friday night fish fry! 😋

Whether you’re craving a classic fish fry or something a little different, we’ve got something for everyone! ❤️

🥩 Tender, juicy steaks
🍝 Fresh pasta dishes
🐟 Our Friday Night Fish Fry
🥗 Fresh, crisp salads
🍽️ And SO MUCH MORE from our full menu!

Bring your family, gather your friends, and let us take care of dinner tonight! Prefer to stay in? Give us a call and place your order to go! 📞

📍 The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E Hwy 33, Newburg, WI 53060
📞 262-685-0012

❤️ Great food, good company, and a little old-fashioned supper club charm!
Come hungry, leave happy, and make us part of your Friday night tradition! 🐟

Milwaukee Brewers The Old Fashioned Supper Club Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers TMJ4 News FOX6 News Milwaukee Wisconsin Supper Clubs Tour Ozaukee Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Explore Wisconsin MKEeeeEats Wanderin Wisconsin Only Wisconsin Things WISN 12 NEWS Milwaukee Brewers Highlights Wisconsin Wisconsin Supper Clubs

10/17/2026

📣CALLING ALL PRIME RIB CONNOISSEURS

Saturday nights are worth savoring at The Old Fashioned Supper Club! We're serving up our delicious Cowboy Butter Prime Rib, tender steaks - cooked to perfection, fresh pasta, and crisp salads. There's something for everyone at the table!

Whether you're looking for our famous prime rib or something from our full menu - we got you!

Don't forget about tonight's Newburg's Annual Witch Walk, starting at 7P 🧙‍♀️ Drink specials, finger food, ghastly concoctions - it's always a fun filled time!

🍴 Dine in or take it to go! Bring the family, grab your favorite people, or skip the dishes and let us do the cooking!

The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E Hwy 33, Newburg, WI 53060
📞 262-685-0012

TMJ4 News Wisconsin Supper Clubs FOX6 News Milwaukee Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers Tour Ozaukee Explore Wisconsin Milwaukee Journal Sentinel MKEeeeEats Wanderin Wisconsin Only Wisconsin Things WISN 12 NEWS Milwaukee Brewers Milwaukee Brewers Highlights

10/16/2026

This weekend we are running our Soup Flight special & we know you won't want to miss this!

🥔 Loaded Baked Potato: topped with cheddar cheese, green onion & baked.
🍛 3-Bean chili: topped with cheese & green onion (add the noodles, we won't tell 🤫).
🍅 Creamy Parmesan Tomato: topped with Parmesan & basil - this one may just become your favorite!

Pair it with a Chicken Club Grilled Cheese for a twist on the classic!

The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E Hwy 33
Newburg WI 53060
262-685-0012

10/16/2026

🎣 FRI-YAY FISH FRY 🎣

Join us for a Wisconsin tradition done right—with something for everyone - including a hand-muddled Old Fashioned!

Not in the mood for fish? We run our FULL MENU on Fridays :)

🌟 Choose from Cod, Lake Perch or Jumbo Shrimp:
🧨 Crispy Fried (Gluten-Free)
🧈 Butter-Poached
🌶️ Blackened

Our Full Menu Includes:
🥩 Hand-cut ribeyes, tenderloin filets & NY Strip steaks
🍖 Hearty Tenderloin Tips
🍝 Fresh pasta dishes
🥗 Crisp salads

🥣 Enjoy our scratch-made soup flight (yes, I said Soup Flight), sip on one of our handcrafted cocktails or mocktails, and save room for our freshly baked desserts 🍰

Whether you're craving a classic Friday Fish Fry or looking to try something new, we've got your table waiting!

The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3497 E. Hwy 33, Newburg, WI 53060
📞 262-685-0012

Come hungry, bring your friends, and let us take care of dinner. We can't wait to serve you!

Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers Wisconsin Supper Clubs FOX6 News Milwaukee TMJ4 News Tour Ozaukee Explore Wisconsin WISN 12 NEWS Milwaukee Brewers One Way Air Of Fort Myers Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Hansen Laundry Milwaukee Brewers Highlights

10/09/2026

🤠 WEEKEND FLAVORS ARE CALLING AT THE OLD FASHIONED SUPPER CLUB! 🔥

Whether you're craving a classic Friday night fish fry or looking ahead to a mouthwatering Saturday night dinner, we've got something delicious waiting for you! 🍽️

🐟 TONIGHT IS FRIDAY NIGHT FISH FRY! 🐟
Join us for that Friday night tradition you know and love, PLUS our LOBSTER ALFREDO SPECIAL! 🦞🧄 Creamy, rich, and packed with flavor, available in HALF or WHOLE orders so you can satisfy that seafood craving!

🥩 AND TOMORROW NIGHT…COWBOY BUTTER PRIME RIB! 🤠
Get ready for a Saturday night worth savoring! We're serving up our delicious Cowboy Butter Prime Rib, tender steaks - cooked to perfection, fresh pasta, and crisp salads. There's something for everyone at the table!

🍴 Dine in or take it to go! Bring the family, grab your favorite people, or skip the dishes and let us do the cooking!

The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E Hwy 33, Newburg, WI 53060
📞 262-685-0012

Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers TMJ4 News Wisconsin Supper Clubs FOX6 News Milwaukee Tour Ozaukee Explore Wisconsin Milwaukee Journal Sentinel MKEeeeEats Wanderin Wisconsin WISN 12 NEWS Only Wisconsin Things Milwaukee Brewers

10/08/2026

Join us for an Old Fashioned Happy Hour!
2 for 1 cocktails, b**r, mocktails & more 🍻

🕓 Daily from 4-5PM
🍤 With purchase of an appetizer (dine in only)
🍹 Rail cocktails, martinis, canned and bottled b**r

The Old Fashioned Supper Club
3498 E Hwy 33
Newburg WI 53060
262-685-0012

TMJ4 News Wisconsin Supper Clubs FOX6 News Milwaukee Wisconsin Supper Club Chasers Only Wisconsin Things Explore Wisconsin One Way Air Of Fort Myers Milwaukee Brewers

Address

3498 Highway 33
Newburg, WI
53060

Opening Hours

Thursday	4pm - 10pm
Friday	4pm - 10pm
Saturday	4pm - 10pm

Telephone

+12626850012

Website

facebook.com

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Old Fashioned Supper Club posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.