Old City Prime

Old City Prime A modern day classic American steakhouse. Old City Prime is a modern day classic American steakhouse. Our menu is a revival of ageless taste.
(1219)

From our fresh oysters and chilled seafood, classic tableside salads, gourmet appetizers, USDA prime aged steaks to breads and desserts from our in house bakery.
​
Indulge in our classic cocktails and boutique wine list, and we think you'll find yourself comfortably enjoying our vision of what today's supper club should be.

Happy Labor Day!🇺🇸We'll be closed Monday, September 7th.See you back at Spring & Main on Tuesday, September 8th!
09/06/2026

Happy Labor Day!🇺🇸
We'll be closed Monday, September 7th.
See you back at Spring & Main on Tuesday, September 8th!

We had the pleasure of celebrating Larry and Michelle last night. Congrats to you both on 13 years of marriage! 💕🌹💘
09/01/2026

We had the pleasure of celebrating Larry and Michelle last night. Congrats to you both on 13 years of marriage! 💕🌹💘

Happy 4 year anniversary to Kelly & Dylan! Thank you for choosing to celebrate with us! 🥂💕
08/31/2026

Happy 4 year anniversary to Kelly & Dylan! Thank you for choosing to celebrate with us! 🥂💕

Final days of summer at Old City Prime. 🌞Our Summer Feature Menu won't be around much longer, so now's the time to come ...
08/31/2026

Final days of summer at Old City Prime. 🌞

Our Summer Feature Menu won't be around much longer, so now's the time to come back for a favorite or try something you haven't had yet.

Enjoy one more taste of the season before these dishes make way for what's next.

Reservations are always recommended.
www.oldcityprime.com/reservations

More than a private space – an evening your guests will remember.From beautifully set tables to exceptional cruisine and...
08/29/2026

More than a private space – an evening your guests will remember.

From beautifully set tables to exceptional cruisine and attentive service, every detail of your event at Old City Prime is designed to make the occasion feel special.

Rehearsal dinners, corporate gatherings, milestone celebrations and more – let us take care of the details while you enjoy the evening.

Learn more and inquire today:
oldcityprime.com/private-events

Save room for something sweet.✨Bright and refreshing or rich and citrusy – our summer desserts are the prefect finish to...
08/24/2026

Save room for something sweet.✨

Bright and refreshing or rich and citrusy – our summer desserts are the prefect finish to your evening.

🍋Light Summer Sorbet Trio – lemon, strawberry & mango

🍰Key West Lime Cheesecake – margarita cheesecake layered with key lime and citrus cream

Which one are you choosing?

Dinner Plans? Make them something special.🍷✨An expertly prepared steak, the perfect glass of wine, and an evening made f...
08/21/2026

Dinner Plans? Make them something special.🍷✨

An expertly prepared steak, the perfect glass of wine, and an evening made for slowing down and enjoying every course.

Join us at Old City Prime in Downtown Lima and make a night of it.
oldcityprime.com/reservations

Join us for Third Thursday in Downtown Lima tonight at Old City Prime.Starting at 5 PM, enjoy:🦐 3 Cocktail Shrimp for $5...
08/20/2026

Join us for Third Thursday in Downtown Lima tonight at Old City Prime.
Starting at 5 PM, enjoy:
🦐 3 Cocktail Shrimp for $5
🦪 3 Oysters for $5
Spend your evening downtown with us and enjoy handcrafted cocktails, exceptional food, and a refined dining experience.
We look forward to seeing you tonight.

08/17/2026

A side worthy of the main course.✨

Slow-simmered string beans, creamy red skin potatoes & Vidalia onions finished with garlic, olive oil and butter.

Featured for a limited time at Old City prime.

Four Summer features. One difficult decision.✨There's still time to enjoy our Summer Chef's Features at Old CIty Prime. ...
08/15/2026

Four Summer features. One difficult decision.✨

There's still time to enjoy our Summer Chef's Features at Old CIty Prime. Which one is calling your name?

Make your reservations:
oldcityprime.com/reservations

Address

215 S Main Street
Lima, OH
45801

Opening Hours

Monday 5pm - 9pm
Tuesday 5pm - 9pm
Wednesday 5pm - 9pm
Thursday 5pm - 9pm
Friday 5pm - 9pm
Saturday 5pm - 9pm

Telephone

+14192277463

Website

, ,

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Old City Prime posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share