Old City Prime

Old City Prime A modern day classic American steakhouse. Old City Prime is a modern day classic American steakhouse. Our menu is a revival of ageless taste.
(1224)

From our fresh oysters and chilled seafood, classic tableside salads, gourmet appetizers, USDA prime aged steaks to breads and desserts from our in house bakery.
​
Indulge in our classic cocktails and boutique wine list, and we think you'll find yourself comfortably enjoying our vision of what today's supper club should be.

05/28/2026

The night starts here.

Before the steak, there's this. Our starters are anything but an afterthought — from fresh Blue Point Oysters and an Iced Seafood Plate to Bacon Wrapped Sea Scallops, Lobster Meat Hot Pot, and our Ahi Tuna & Spicy Crab Sushi Tower.

Something for every taste. Every time.

Happy 2 Year Anniversary from all of us at Old City Prime. We hope your evening has been full of love, laughter, and gre...
05/28/2026

Happy 2 Year Anniversary from all of us at Old City Prime. We hope your evening has been full of love, laughter, and great memories, and that our food was just the finishing touch that made it even more special. Thank you for celebrating with us tonight.

Not every steakhouse does pasta. We do it right. Our Wild Mushroom Black Pepper Ravioli is a study in balance — the dept...
05/26/2026

Not every steakhouse does pasta. We do it right.

Our Wild Mushroom Black Pepper Ravioli is a study in balance — the depth of wild mushrooms, the warmth of black pepper, all wrapped in tender pasta and finished with a rich parmesan mushroom cream sauce.

A dish that earns its place on a Prime menu.

We’re closed today. See you Tuesday!
05/25/2026

We’re closed today. See you Tuesday!

This is what we strive for — every table, every night. Quality you can taste. Service you can feel. A place worth coming...
05/20/2026

This is what we strive for — every table, every night.

Quality you can taste. Service you can feel. A place worth coming back to.

We’re excited to welcome Q’s BBQ, opening right across the street from Old City Prime!THIS TUESDAY!! 🤠🎉This community sh...
05/15/2026

We’re excited to welcome Q’s BBQ, opening right across the street from Old City Prime!

THIS TUESDAY!! 🤠🎉

This community shows up, supports local, and takes care of its neighbors. 💯🥳

If you’re excited to check them out, drop a comment, share this post, and give it a like. Let’s give Q’s BBQ a strong welcome from day one.

05/15/2026

The tableside Caesar isn't just a salad. It's a moment.

New flavors have arrived at Old City Prime. ✨🥩From premium Wagyu selections to elevated chef features, our new Feature M...
05/13/2026

New flavors have arrived at Old City Prime. ✨🥩

From premium Wagyu selections to elevated chef features, our new Feature Menu is one you won’t want to miss.

Make your reservation today: https://www.oldcityprime.com/reservations

Address

215 S Main Street
Lima, OH
45801

Opening Hours

Monday 5pm - 9pm
Tuesday 5pm - 9pm
Wednesday 5pm - 9pm
Thursday 5pm - 9pm
Friday 5pm - 9pm
Saturday 5pm - 9pm

Telephone

+14192277463

Website

http://oldcityprime.com/menu, http://oldcityprime.com/live-entertainment

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Old City Prime posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share