06/05/2026
When youre in the mood for an old-school supper club night done right, Black Otter Supper Club in Hortonville, WI is the move. You pull into the lot and step inside to that warm glow, low chatter, and the kind of place that already smells like prime rib and buttered rolls. You start with a classic brandy Old Fashioned, then dig into tender prime rib, crispy walleye, juicy steaks, and a salad bar that feels like a tradition. You dont skip the cheesy hash browns, the fresh bread, or the sweet finish that turns maybe dessert into a sure thing. Youll find the service quick and friendly, the portions generous, and the whole vibe relaxed and welcoming without feeling rushed. You leave full, happy, and already planning who youre bringing back next time.