Toasted Turtle Tavern

Directions Website

Toasted Turtle Tavern Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Toasted Turtle Tavern, Bar, 51425 State Road 19, Elkhart, IN.

The owners of Family Value Flooring were one of the first businesses to reach out and ask to contribute to the Find Toas...
10/16/2026

The owners of Family Value Flooring were one of the first businesses to reach out and ask to contribute to the Find Toasty prize package! They’re a great company to work with. We appreciate you. 

Good Morning kids….!Who says you can’t have Happy Hour in the morning? Wednesday-Thursdays 8AM-11AM.. $5 Bloddy Marys, M...
10/15/2026

Good Morning kids….!
Who says you can’t have Happy Hour in the morning? Wednesday-Thursdays 8AM-11AM..
$5 Bloddy Marys, Mimosas, Aperol Spritz!
Four breakfast specials! You are invited!

It was a great night for a Toasty Celebration! Thanks to the generosity of this amazing community we were able to presen...
10/14/2026

It was a great night for a Toasty Celebration!
Thanks to the generosity of this amazing community we were able to present Brittani Ann Crowley with a total of $15,947 in gifts, cash and charitable contributions! The charities Brittani chose were Angels in the Attic, Cultivate Food Rescue and Elkhart High School Band Boosters!
I am grateful….  Thank you all.

It’s Back……….! Fresh North Atlantic Cold Water Dinner $28SUNDAY SUNDAY SUNDAY…. 4-8 PM! You are invited! With a limited ...
10/14/2026

It’s Back……….!
Fresh North Atlantic Cold Water Dinner $28
SUNDAY SUNDAY SUNDAY…. 4-8 PM!
You are invited! With a limited supply of fresh lobster coming in we will not be reserving lobsters or taking reservations. We will be offering our lobster dinner on the first come first serve basis.

Not very photogenic but it’s mighty tasty! Tennessee Wh***ey Goat Cheese Golden panko crusted goat cheese accompanied by...
10/07/2026

Not very photogenic but it’s mighty tasty!

Tennessee Wh***ey Goat Cheese
Golden panko crusted goat cheese accompanied by a Jack Daniels apple jam, toasted walnuts, dried toasted crostini’s!

Blood Orange Pepper Seared Salmon North Atlantic Faroe Island Salmon lightly dusted with blood orange Terra Spice served...
10/07/2026

Blood Orange Pepper Seared Salmon

North Atlantic Faroe Island Salmon lightly dusted with blood orange Terra Spice served with a creamy roasted garlic and spinach risotto, seasonal veggie, finished with charred leek cream. The new features have arrived.

Pasta Alla VodkaGrilled chicken breast, bronze cut Italian Durum spaghetti in a vodka red Sunday sauce, parmigiana chee...
10/07/2026

Pasta Alla Vodka
Grilled chicken breast, bronze cut Italian Durum spaghetti in a vodka red Sunday sauce, parmigiana cheese, fresh basil.
I introduce to this week’s feature!

Any fans out there of chicken and biscuits?Chicken tenderloin breast lightly dusted, and fried golden, served on a butt...
10/07/2026

Any fans out there of chicken and biscuits?
Chicken tenderloin breast lightly dusted, and fried golden, served on a buttermilk biscuit with a schunizzle of hot honey. Hash brown casserole in our signature sausage gravy for those I like to dip..
We’re trying to decide whether this should be on our future menu or not? Comment below, please. ⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️⬇️

Now that Toasty has been found, I’m curious how many of you went out looking for him? Whether it be for a couple of minu...
10/05/2026

Now that Toasty has been found, I’m curious how many of you went out looking for him? Whether it be for a couple of minutes, couple of hours or days or did some research online.. How many went the BOG and walked right by him but never stopped?
A local news station is wanting to do a follow up report, we’re curious. Thanks for playing..

Cam

Address

51425 State Road 19
Elkhart, IN
46514

Opening Hours

Wednesday 8am - 9pm
Thursday 8am - 9pm
Friday 8am - 9pm
Saturday 8am - 9pm
Sunday 8am - 8pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Toasted Turtle Tavern posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category