Toasted Turtle Tavern

Toasted Turtle Tavern Contact information, map and directions, contact form, opening hours, services, ratings, photos, videos and announcements from Toasted Turtle Tavern, Bar, 51425 State Road 19, Elkhart, IN.

Hump Day Happy Hour Weds-Thurs 8-11AM ! Steak n Eggs $10$5 Aperol Spritz$5 Mimosa$5 Bloody Mary’s! $10 Steak n Eggs Mari...
09/02/2026

Hump Day Happy Hour Weds-Thurs 8-11AM !
Steak n Eggs $10
$5 Aperol Spritz
$5 Mimosa
$5 Bloody Mary’s!

$10 Steak n Eggs
Marinated Pork Ribeye, sliced potatoes,
2-eggs and toast…

Lobster Fun-Day Sunday has returned! Fresh North Atlantic Lobster $28..Comment below “Reserve Lobster Please” to reserve...
08/28/2026

Lobster Fun-Day Sunday has returned!
Fresh North Atlantic Lobster $28..
Comment below “Reserve Lobster Please” to reserve your lobster dinner for this Sunday August 30th. Dinner will be served starting at 4PM. There will be a limited supply of lobsters flown in so please respond to reserve.

To ensure your lobster order is confirmed the Deadline to reserve your lobster is 5:00 Friday! This is a Dine In only feature.

It’s Thursday! Fresh Oysters have arrived! Raw, Garlic Parm, Rockefeller or have them your way! You are invited!
08/27/2026

It’s Thursday! Fresh Oysters have arrived!
Raw, Garlic Parm, Rockefeller or have them your way! You are invited!

08/27/2026

The ultra talented Jason Sapen was the first guest to tickle the ivory at Toasted Turtle! Thank you Jason for the impromptu lunch visit and music!

Ok ladies, it’s a Mimosa Kinda Morning! Drop the kids off at school, skip the gym, meet at the Turtle for $5 Mimosas, Ap...
08/27/2026

Ok ladies, it’s a Mimosa Kinda Morning!
Drop the kids off at school, skip the gym, meet at the Turtle for $5 Mimosas, Aperol Spritz or Bloody Marys! You are invited!
We call it the True Judgement Free Zone!

Coconut Shrimp in the house…. Hand breaded Argentina Red Shrimp, Captain Morgan spiced rum pineapple sweet chili dipping...
08/26/2026

Coconut Shrimp in the house….
Hand breaded Argentina Red Shrimp, Captain Morgan spiced rum pineapple sweet chili dipping sauce! Oh My Oh My!

Fresh Oysters have arrived! Premium Chesapeake Bay oysters, freshly shucked on the half shell, garlic butter baked or Ro...
08/26/2026

Fresh Oysters have arrived!
Premium Chesapeake Bay oysters, freshly shucked on the half shell, garlic butter baked or Rockefeller style! Plump, clean and briny with a smooth, slightly sweet finish.
Are there any Oyster fans out here?

Hump Day Happy Hour 8-11AMSteak N Eggs $10Center Cut Pork Ribeye, two eggs, tators, toast served with a smile! This is ...
08/26/2026

Hump Day Happy Hour 8-11AM
Steak N Eggs $10
Center Cut Pork Ribeye, two eggs, tators, toast served with a smile! This is a Dine in only feature!

We’re excited about our newest addition in our new addition at the Turtle. A family heirloom from the owner’s family, bu...
08/25/2026

We’re excited about our newest addition in our new addition at the Turtle. A family heirloom from the owner’s family, built in 1897 in Chicago. It’s been preserved for over 129 years and still delivers an amazing sound! If you’re an experienced pianist you’re welcome to stop in and play during your next visit.

Address

51425 State Road 19
Elkhart, IN
46514

Opening Hours

Wednesday 8am - 9pm
Thursday 8am - 9pm
Friday 8am - 9pm
Saturday 8am - 9pm
Sunday 8am - 8pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Toasted Turtle Tavern posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category