Nick Stoner Inn Seafood & Steakhouse

Nick Stoner Inn Seafood & Steakhouse We are a family run restaurant who take pride in all we create. Hand cut PRIME steaks fresh seafood & Farm to table is our goal! Support local!

LOCAL Farm Fresh homemade specials that will leave you in “awe”
Relax in a very casual and stunning atmosphere. Nick Stoner Inn is a Seafood & Steakhouse specializing in fresh seafood and in house hand cut steaks grilled and cooked to perfection. We offer unique creative dishes in a wide range of seafood, steak and handheld foods. Our restaurant will be sure to satisfy everyone’s taste buds! We have a wide range of locally craft beer on tap (19) craft liquor, and local NY wines from vineyard’s in the Finger Lakes! If your looking for the perfect venue to host any event, wedding, bridal jack and Jill party, etc.... we have the most beautiful venue and unlimited options and can create “together” the most perfect menu for your special day......so give us a call.

Beautiful Faroe Island salmon! Yum 🤤
09/17/2026

Beautiful Faroe Island salmon! Yum 🤤

Wow Roswell family farms….you killed it with these Tomahawk Pork Chops! Amazing! Thank you! 🙏
09/17/2026

Wow Roswell family farms….you killed it with these Tomahawk Pork Chops!
Amazing! Thank you! 🙏

09/17/2026

We so forgot to add our LOBSTER 🦞 pasta dish on the new menu!
Made with live Lobster’s

Pappardelle fresh pasta tossed in Morgie’s delectable vodka sauce with chunks of fresh lobster 🦞 prepared daily!

Good morning NSI family, We have a weekend full of delicious specials and will be introducing some of our new menu items...
09/17/2026

Good morning NSI family,
We have a weekend full of delicious specials and will be introducing some of our new menu items.

Note….As we have not yet finalised our NEW seasonal menu there will be items not available this week that are on our resent menu.

As we carefully crafted and created dishes/entrees that are mostly all Gluten Free and sautéed in olive oil and herb 🌿 infused olive oils. Natural Spices/seasonings with Himalayan/Celtic salt only!

Come on out Friday night. 5-8pm and say goodbye to our very own Magic Man Bill Bing as he heads off to Florida for the winter 😢 thank you for a memorable summer Bill, we will miss you!

New Fall hours…..
Thursday 4-8pm…..
Friday 4-8pm (Magic Man Bill Bing 5-8)
Saturday 12-8pm
Sunday 12-5pm

Soups & chowders…
~Charlie’s loaded seafood chowder
~Rebecca’s sweet savoury butternut bisque….
~3 cheese FO soup

⭐ Bar special……

~ The new NSI fried chicken sandwich…. (GFree without the bun available)
Juicy Fried chicken on a bed of arugula/spinach house made pickled onions & pickles 🥒 drizzed with a creamy Sriracha sauce and toasted on a garlicky butter roll made by the dolgeville bread basket! Served With FF….Yum yum yum 😋 $18

- NEW….Smoked Pork belly taco 🌮 served in our delicious house made garlic and herb tortillas!
(Local pork from the Roswell Family Farm) served with FF $18

Entree’s…….

~ NEW….House made (creamy, tender, juicy and mouth watering delicious) MEATBALLS served over fresh pasta with your choice gluten free sauce’s and a loaf of fresh made bread 🍞 $28
~Morgie’s vodka sauce
~Marinara sauce
~Alfredo
GF Pasta available

~ NEW…JUICY TENDER Tomahawk Pork Chops from the Roswell family farm, grilled on the char-broiler to perfection topped with Rebeccas signature (local maple) cinnamon butter,
Mashed potato’s, side of our signature mushroom gravy and grilled local corn on the cob 🌽

~ NEW SURF & TURF Special…… 10oz in house cut NY strip, grilled shrimp, baked potato and homemade bread $42

~ NSI SIGNATURE Steak & Seafood special…. The ultimate celebration entree! THE WOW Factor!
Your choice Steak 🥩 topped w/ bacon wrapped scallops, colossal shrimp, 12-14oz lobster 🦞 tail and your choice side (GF), of DBB bread 🍞

~ Local Farm fresh chicken breast, grilled shrimp & broccoli 🥦 with our daughter Morgan’s delicious VODKA sauce or Alfredo over fresh pasta or over our NEW sweet corn 🌽 rice. (GFree)
_______________________

⭐️ NEW Appetizers
~ NEW…Charlie’s loaded Seafood chowder TOPPED with……………..🦞Lobster & Corn Fritters {Gluten Free} $16 (this is going to be a new favorite!)

~ NEW…… fresh, sweet and delicious mussels sautéed in a garlicky and a little kick of spice, in a savoury marinara sauce with garlic toast for dipping. $18
________________________

~Grilled Salmon BLACKENED or……drizzled with our maple bourbon sauce, served with grilled zucchini and our new sweet corn 🌽 rice {Gluten free}

🥩 Steaks ….. in house cut by Charlie.
Filet
NY Strip
Ribeye

Apps…..
Smoked pork belly app.
NSI Mexican street corn 🌽 local sweet corn
Fresh Oysters 🦪 (GF)
Bacon wrapped scallops(GF)
Colossal shrimp 🍤 cocktail(GF)
~ NEW…Fresh delicious mussels in a spicy garlicky marinara sauce with garlic toast.
NSI Poutine (GF)
Ahi tuna app. (GF)
FO Soup
Charlie’s loaded seafood chowder (GF)

ALWAYS……in house ground steak Burgers or local family farm burger meat🍔

Tacos 🌮 pork belly, steak, shrimp, or ahi tuna made with Rebecca’s homemade garlic and herb tortillas! No additives or preservatives.

Wings, soup, chowder and more.

(It’s so important to Support local businesses.)

1810 state hwy 10 caroga lake ny
Call 📞 518-835-8039 during business hours
Or message the page for reservations

Good morning NSI family, even though we won’t be launching our new menu this week as anticipated, we will however be int...
09/15/2026

Good morning NSI family, even though we won’t be launching our new menu this week as anticipated, we will however be introducing some of the NEW menu items that will be on our revamped menu!
We hope you will visit us this week and try a few of our delicious
And savoury dishes we have created. We are excited for this new change!

A very important message about our ANNUAL Halloween 🎃 Party many of you have been asking about.
We have decided to take this year off….. but are planning something bigger than we have ever done before, so keep a look out 👀 for an amazing upcoming event for this summer 2027. 👻🎃
Sad I know, but we are in the process of planning a low key Halloween weekend with music 🎵, dinner and tastings, that will be so much fun. Halloween 🎃 Weekend stay available so inquiring within.

You do not want to miss….Magic Man Bill Bing’s last night of the season till next spring 2027.
Come and see him on Friday 5-8pm and witness his magic and say goodbye as he heads to Florida for the winter ❄️

Thank you everyone for all your continued support and love 🥰 local family businesses NEED your support to survive moving forward into our slower season.

Have a blessed week and see you Thursday for the launching of some of our new menu items!

1810 state hwy 10
Caroga lake NY
518-835-8039
For overnight stay text 518-705-5126

09/08/2026

Good morning NSI family.
Reminder we are closed this weekend for family obligations, upcoming “winter” renovations that need to be completed before winter arrives….and to host the Annual Nick Stoner Trailers ⛳️ golf tournament on Saturday! We hope you all have a great turnout and a fun day playing a sport WE as a family love to play!

Prayer 🙏 circle needed for a very special man and his wonderful family Patrick Flander! Gods got your Back, always! We adore you 🥰

See you all back here on Thursday September 17th with a brand new MENU!!!!

PS…. We hope all the littles and teachers have a wonderful first day of school and week! Back to reality lol. 😜

Good afternoon NSI family. We have some exciting news to share and we think 🤔 because of the rising COST of LIFE, you wi...
09/03/2026

Good afternoon NSI family.
We have some exciting news to share and we think 🤔 because of the rising COST of LIFE, you will be happy to know, we are revamping our menu drastically to accommodate this ever changing economy for all of us.

Starting today we will be throwing out some of our new menu items and introducing the NEW menu in a few weeks.

1 one ☝️ menu for both bar and dining. Simple, delicious and affordable for everyone.

Hope you all have a blessed labor day weekend!

Next weekend we will be closed Friday Saturday and Sunday for the Nick Stoner Trailers golf ⛳️ tournament and family obligations.
We will see you back on Thursday the 17th for the launching of our new MENU!

1810 state hwy 10
Caroga lake NY
Message the page for table reservations or inquiring about a night stay with us @ 518-705-5126

Another fun weekend here in Caroga Lake hosted by Shermans/Caroga Arts/CACHappy September 1st…..We have a weekend full o...
09/01/2026

Another fun weekend here in Caroga Lake hosted by Shermans/Caroga Arts/CAC

Happy September 1st…..
We have a weekend full of delicious seasonal favorites that will leave you craving for more.
Starting with…….

~ NSI’s Butter nut bisque……. Sweet buttery, local maple, 🍁 cinnamon flavored deliciousness….that screams fall season has arrived. Creamy goodness in every bite.
{Pair it with a loaf of Dolgeville Bread basket bread 🍞 served with our new whipped maple cinnamon butter.}

Bar special……
~ Chicken Parmesan sandwich is back….served on a toasted garlic loaf with marinara sauce or TRY it with Morgan’s amazing vodka sauce served with garlic Parmesan fries.
_______________________

~ NSI creamy cheesy garlicky Spinach artichoke dip served house made corn chips, sour cream , house made pico and cheese
Gluten free!

~ NEW…… Dolgeville Bread Basket dinner loaf…. Warmed in the oven & Served with a house made whipped…maple 🍁 cinnamon butter! (Local maple syrup)

Burger 🍔 of the week…..

~ New NSI breakfast burger……
Fresh ground steak burger topped with melted provolone cheddar and Swiss, fresh farm egg 🥚 and bacon, served on a toasted garlic butter homemade roll & fries

NSI signature
Autumn sangria 🍂 🍁 🍎 🍹 ……made with local cider and apples from Roger’s!

Taking reservations for table seating and we welcome walk ins.
Message the page.

Rooms available call or text @ 518-705~ 5126

1810 state hwy 10
Caroga lake NY

Good morning NSI family and friends.We have been putting together a new business WEBSITE and are adding a special place ...
08/31/2026

Good morning NSI family and friends.
We have been putting together a new business WEBSITE and are adding a special place for EVENTS & viewing our beautiful rooms and space for all your special celebrations and requests.

Perfectly designed for any special occasion all year round!

We are now BOOKING for Christmas 🎄 celebrations in a beautifully decorated space fit for both corporate and (private) larger family gatherings along with smaller more INTIMATE Events or gathering.
Our stunning space has a very intimate rustic charm, with a very chic romantic, elegant atmosphere. It’s absolutely beautiful.

We have the perfect space for bachelorette and bachelor parties/JACK & JILL and more.

We offer lodging with homemade cooked breakfast catered to your own personal stay. {Bed and Breakfast 🍳 feel}

NEWLY added…… our beautiful Hearthstone retreat. {A project we have been working on for years is finally complete.} Inquire within.

Lodging & dining for the most beautiful Adirondack season is approaching!
Leaf 🍁 peeking season is here!

Our amenities are unique and all we offer is endless.

Also offering custom charcuterie boards…. GF upon request
And….. speciality cakes, cupcakes and cookies. Acquire within.

Golfing and biking 🚴 and so much more! Call or text for more information and package getaways!
Your weekend getaway awaits!
518-705-5126

NOTE…….

Goodmorning! A couple announcements for upcoming dates! We will be open Thursday 9/10 but will be closed Friday- Sunday 9/11-9/13. We will also be closed Saturday 10/03 and Sunday 10/04 for a family event!

Good morning NSI family, end of summer is approaching and we are blessed with another beautiful weekend and a country fe...
08/27/2026

Good morning NSI family, end of summer is approaching and we are blessed with another beautiful weekend and a country fest in little Caroga Lake!

Saturday and Sunday….Come on out and support all the businesses in Caroga! So much fun!

End of Summer hours…..

Thursday 4-8pm…..$8 steamed clams!
Friday 4-8pm
Saturday 12-8pm
Sunday 12-5pm

End of Summer weekend specials….

⭐ Bar special……

~ In house ground burger 🍔 organic grown mushroom & Swiss burger topped with bacon and a side of our horseradish mayo aioli served with garlic and herb 🌿 fries.

- Ahi tuna taco 🌮 served in our fresh made in house…..garlic and herb tortillas!

Entree’s…….

~ NEW SURF & TURF Special…… 10oz in house cut NY strip, grilled shrimp, baked potato salad and homemade bread $39.95

~Blackened Swordfish with your choice side, salad and homemade bread…. Back by popular choice!

~ NSI SIGNATURE Steak & Seafood special…. The ultimate celebration entree! THE WOW Factor!
Your choice Steak 🥩 topped w/ bacon wrapped scallops, colossal shrimp, 12-14oz lobster 🦞 tail and your choice side, salad and a loaf of DBB bread 🍞 {Gluten Free}

~ Local Farm fresh chicken breast, and grilled shrimp with our daughter Morgan’s delicious VODKA sauce over zoodles/zucchini noodles {Gluten Free} or fresh pasta

~ Charlie’s loaded Seafood chowder {Gluten Free}

~Grilled Salmon BLACKENED or……drizzled with our maple bourbon sauce, and served with grilled zucchini. {Gluten free}

🥩 Steaks ….. in house cut by Charlie.
Filet
NY Strip
Ribeye

Apps…..
Mexican street corn 🌽
Fresh Oysters 🦪 (GF)
Bacon wrapped scallops(GF)
Colossal shrimp 🍤 cocktail(GF)
Little neck Clams (GF) & wine steamers
NSI Poutine (GF)
Ahi tuna app. (GF)
Real crabmeat…..Crab cake 🦀 stuffed mushrooms 🍄‍🟫 (GF)
FO Soup
Charlie’s loaded seafood chowder (GF)

Regular menu always!
Lighter side menu and bar menu all weekend long!

ALWAYS……in house ground steak Burgers 🍔

Tacos 🌮 chicken, steak, shrimp, or ahi tuna
Wings, soup, chowder and more.

(It’s so important to Support local businesses.)

1810 state hwy 10 caroga lake ny
Call 📞 518-835-8039 during business hours
Or message the page for reservations

Address

1810 State Highway 10
Caroga Lake, NY
12032

Opening Hours

Thursday 4pm - 8pm
Friday 4pm - 8pm
Saturday 12pm - 8pm
Sunday 12pm - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Nick Stoner Inn Seafood & Steakhouse posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share