fatfish on the Water

fatfish on the Water REOPENING APRIL 2025! Overlooking Long Island's gorgeous Great South Bay, fatfish is a lively Mediterranean-inspired seafood destination.
(2250)

Sip into summer with our handcrafted alcohol-free favorites:🍉 Watermelon Basil Refresher: muddled basil, watermelon puré...
06/08/2026

Sip into summer with our handcrafted alcohol-free favorites:

🍉 Watermelon Basil Refresher: muddled basil, watermelon purée, fresh lime juice & club soda
🌿 Mint Basil Limeade: muddled basil & mint, fresh lime juice, simple syrup & club soda
🍓 Sunset Tea: muddled strawberries, raspberries, blackberries & mint with iced tea, fresh lemon juice & club soda
🍍 Virgin Piña Colada: a tropical classic, blended and refreshing

Perfect for a sunny day on the bay ☀️🌊

Which one are you ordering first?

SummerSips Northport LongIslandEats DrinkLocal MocktailMenu

Our Artisan Cheese Board features a curated selection of cheeses chosen by Chef & Owner Brian Valdini during his travels...
06/07/2026

Our Artisan Cheese Board features a curated selection of cheeses chosen by Chef & Owner Brian Valdini during his travels and culinary experiences throughout Europe and beyond 🧀✨

From the citrusy notes of Humboldt Fog to the rich complexity of Stocking Hall Cheddar and the buttery finish of Cornelia Reserve by , each cheese brings its own unique character to the board.

Served with seasonal accompaniments and perfect for sharing by the water

longislandeats seafoodandwine northfork foodie

Our Artisan Cheese Board features a curated selection of cheeses chosen by Chef & Owner Brian Valdini during his travels...
06/05/2026

Our Artisan Cheese Board features a curated selection of cheeses chosen by Chef & Owner Brian Valdini during his travels and culinary experiences throughout Europe and beyond 🧀✨

From the citrusy notes of Humboldt Fog to the rich complexity of Stocking Hall Cheddar and the buttery finish of Cornelia Reserve from , each cheese brings its own unique character to the board

Served with seasonal accompaniments and perfect for sharing by the water🌊

Which cheese are you trying first?!✨

longislandeats seafoodandwine northfork foodie

06/05/2026
Our Artisan Cheese Board features a curated selection of cheeses chosen by Chef & Owner Brian Valdini during his travels...
06/05/2026

Our Artisan Cheese Board features a curated selection of cheeses chosen by Chef & Owner Brian Valdini during his travels and culinary experiences throughout Europe and beyond 🧀✨

From the citrusy notes of Humboldt Fog to the rich complexity of Stocking Hall Cheddar and the buttery finish of Cornelia Reserve, each cheese brings its own unique character to the board.

Served with seasonal accompaniments and perfect for sharing by the water.

Which cheese are you trying first?!✨

longislandeats seafoodandwine northfork foodie

A week at Fatfish 🌊✨From Lobster Fest Mondays and Taste of Spain Tuesdays to Sunset Social Wednesdays, Tapas & Wine Thur...
06/03/2026

A week at Fatfish 🌊✨

From Lobster Fest Mondays and Taste of Spain Tuesdays to Sunset Social Wednesdays, Tapas & Wine Thursdays, and our daily Tapas Lunch specials there’s always something new by the bay 🍷🦞

Waterfront dining, rotating specials, live music, and summer sunsets all season long

Which special are you trying first?!✨

seafoodrestaurant tapas longisland northfork summerdining

Choose any 3 tapas for $45 and enjoy waterfront dining all season long ✨ From steak skewers to crispy potatoes and fresh...
06/02/2026

Choose any 3 tapas for $45 and enjoy waterfront dining all season long ✨ From steak skewers to crispy potatoes and fresh bites by the bay, lunch just got better at Fatfish

Pictured here: our Steak Skewers, Tuna Tostada & Patatas Bravas 🤍

Available daily

longislandlife waterfrontdining tapas longislandfoodie suffolkcounty foodie seafoodrestaurant fatfishonthewater

Summer on the bay starts now 🌊Our official seasonal hours are here and we’re now open 7 days a week ✨Join us waterfront ...
06/01/2026

Summer on the bay starts now 🌊

Our official seasonal hours are here and we’re now open 7 days a week ✨

Join us waterfront for fresh seafood, cocktails, live music, tapas nights, and sunsets on the bay

Reserve your table on Resy 🦞

seaside dining seafoodrestaurant longislandfoodie bayviews coastaldining summervibes

Our new Tuna has arrived ✨Black pepper & coriander encrusted tuna served with pickled red onion, ginger orange salad, Fr...
05/30/2026

Our new Tuna has arrived ✨

Black pepper & coriander encrusted tuna served with pickled red onion, ginger orange salad, French beans, lemon basmati rice, spicy lemon mayo, and wasabi 🌊

Fresh flavors, crafted on the bay
Reserve now on Resy

waterfrontdining longislandeats foodie chefcrafted summerdining bayviews coastaldining

05/27/2026

Long Island summers start on the bay 🌊

Fresh seafood, handcrafted cocktails, live music, and waterfront views all summer long at Fatfish

From the kitchen to the dockside tables, every detail is crafted for nights by the water ✨

Book your table now on Resy

Photo + video credit: and

longislandeats bayviews summeronlongisland seafoodrestaurant hiddengem longislandfoodie coastalvibes

Address

28 Cottage Avenue
Bay Shore, NY
11706

Opening Hours

Tuesday 11:30am - 9pm
Wednesday 11:30am - 9pm
Thursday 11:30am - 9pm
Friday 11:30am - 9:30pm
Saturday 11:30am - 9:30pm
Sunday 11am - 5:30pm

Telephone

+16316662899

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when fatfish on the Water posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Establishment

Send a message to fatfish on the Water:

Share