Thirsty Whale Tavern

08/21/2026

We’re thrilled to unveil our new menu offerings—come taste the difference! Our farm-to-table steak is sourced from Maple Lane Farm, a local 5th-generation farm, ensuring naturally raised, fed, and expertly butchered beef.

Everyday Lunch Special: $22 – 8 oz N.Y. Strip topped with garlic herb butter, served with your choice of a side.

Lobster Tail Appetizer: $15
Twin Lobster Tail Appetizer: $28

Surf & Turf: $38- 8oz N.Y. Strip topped with garlic and herb butter, along with a locally source lobster tail, and a choice of side

08/19/2026

Update: This is a very good lesson for all of us. We all make mistakes it just matters what you do afterwards these gentlemen did the right thing and came in and paid for what they took. Thank you to everyone the comments were the best.

If you are part of this group or know anyone in this group. You have until close of business today to come pay for the alcohol you stole or I will be going to the police and filing a report.

08/03/2026

07/27/2026

We love island connections and what they do in the community.

Make plans to dine out on MDI this Saturday during Island Connections' Dine-Around Day! So many fabulous local restaurants have signed up to participate this year, be sure to visit one or more on Saturday, August 1st, and tell them THANK YOU for their commitment to community on MDI. Visit https://www.islconnections.org/dine-around-day for a detailed list and interactive map.

07/16/2026

Today at 2:00pm at the criterion free to all ages. Don’t miss out.

06/05/2026

Now open for breakfast Togo 6am to 10 am. Come grab a coffee or assorted breakfast sandwiches hash browns and more.

05/02/2026

We invite you to watch the Kentucky Derby with us and enjoy a mint julep.