03/09/2026
A delayed wrap up of a Tony's Taphouse b**r night on Fri 28 Aug.
A blind tasting (7x attendees) of 6x barley w**es was the main event, with the b**rs presented as follows:
- at 12.5C (55F) degrees
- unidentified on each paddle,
- with all 6x b**r bottles randomly available for viewing, and
- with each person seeking to identify each b**r and rate it individually.
The twist was that 5x b**rs were A Deal with the Devil (ADWTD) variants (1x single oaked, 1x double oaked, 2x triple oaked, 1x quadruple oaked) and the other was a Horus led collaboration with Anchorage seeking to imitate/replicate ADWTD. The question posed was: 'does time and/or number of barrels make a difference to appreciation of the b**r'.
Each person gave each b**r an Untappd score and also ranked the b**r on their paddle (1 is best, 6 is worst). The lowest total of ranking points determined the winner. There were minor differences between final ranking on paddle versus final ranking by Untappd score - but ranking on paddle was used to decide final placement.
The results were as follows:
1. Horus Fletcher One 2025 (aged 60 months) 4.77
2. ADWTD TO B15 2024 (aged 26 months) 4.80
3. ADWTD QO B3 2023 (aged 28 months) 4.68
4. ADWTD DO B9 (can) 2025 (aged 21 months) 4.63
5. ADWTD TO B8 2024 (aged 26 months) 4.58
6. ADWTD SO 2026 (aged 17 months) 4.52
Based upon these blind results, there was no absolute relationship between time in barrel or number of barrels exposed to, however the highest rated b**r was in barrel by far the longest time (60 months), and the lowest rated b**r in barrel by far the shortest time (17 months), with both b**rs only exposed to a single barrel. As such, for this tasting, there is an argument to say that time in barrel, rather than quantity of barrels exposed to, is the determining factor in drinker appreciation.
This was fun to do and I thank my friends who were involved for humouring me in my b**r nerdery π